I strongly support The Reporter remaining an official newspaper of Delaware County. The circumstances surrounding the county’s decision to remove the publication deserve considerably more scrutiny than they have received. Although the Delaware County Board of Supervisors has cited financial considerations, I have serious doubts that saving taxpayers money was the actual motivation behind this decision.
When we consider the substantial amounts of public funding directed toward the foster care system, where evidence-based care is not consistently provided, while agencies and organizations continue to receive significant financial support without demonstrable success or meaningful outcomes, it becomes difficult to accept cost as a convincing justification for removing a local newspaper. If fiscal responsibility is truly the county’s priority, perhaps greater scrutiny should be directed toward how public funds are allocated, how services are delivered, and who ultimately benefits financially. A newspaper that serves an important role in holding government accountable should not become a casualty of misplaced financial priorities.
Supervisor Jerry Vernold’s explanation, “I’m from Hancock,” is hardly an informed or substantive justification for voting against The Reporter and in favor of the Hancock Herald. Personal familiarity or geographic affiliation should never substitute for objective reasoning when decisions involve public resources and the public’s access to information. Countywide decisions should be based on the merits of the publications, not personal loyalties or hometown affiliations.
The Hancock Herald is owned and published by Cindy Ray Argiros, whose name appears as a defendant in numerous civil proceedings in 2026 involving allegations brought by former students of the Family Foundation School. These proceedings reportedly involve allegations of sexual abuse, physical and psychological abuse, negligence, concealment of allegations, and racketeering. These remain allegations, not established findings. Nevertheless, the number and seriousness of these proceedings warrant public awareness and appropriate scrutiny when considering the individuals and organizations involved in public business.
There is another issue I believe deserves acknowledgment. My incoming Hamden Supervisor, whose term begins Jan. 1, 2027, is the brother of the owner of The Reporter, while our town clerk is his sister. These familial relationships raise legitimate questions about potential conflicts of interest and the importance of transparency in local government. In fact, these relationships were among the considerations that informed my decision not to support his election effort. I recognize that bringing this up adds another layer of complexity to an already contentious issue; however, that is precisely why disclosure, transparency, and consistent ethical standards must apply equally to everyone, regardless of personal or political relationships.
I strongly encourage the incoming Hamden Supervisor, Wayne Shepard, and every member of the Delaware County Board of Supervisors to look beyond personal relationships, political connections, and geographic loyalties when making decisions about our local news sources. Public office carries an ethical responsibility to act in the best interests of the community, not according to personal affiliations or relationships. Independent journalism is essential to that responsibility, particularly when it comes to scrutinizing the very institutions entrusted with serving the public.
A local newspaper should not need personal or political connections to receive fair consideration. Nor should public officials be able to disadvantage a publication simply because they disagree with its reporting. The public deserves an objective process, consistent standards, and decisions that can withstand scrutiny.
The people of Delaware County deserve independent journalism, government transparency, and accountability. I believe The Reporter serves an important role in fulfilling those responsibilities, and I urge the Board of Supervisors to reconsider its decision and support The Reporter’s continued designation as an official county newspaper in 2027 and beyond.
Dotti Howe
Hamden