DELHI - Delaware Academy’s varsity football team will not continue in the postseason after Section IV upheld a decision requiring the Bulldogs to forfeit their Nov. 7 victory over Deposit-Hancock and relinquish their playoff eligibility.
The decision was confirmed Friday, Nov. 13, in a statement from Delaware Academy Superintendent Carey Schultz, following the district’s unsuccessful appeal to Section IV. Deposit-Hancock subsequently took Delaware Academy’s place in the championship game against Tioga, falling to the team by a score of 33-8.
The district learned Thursday, Nov. 12, that the Bulldogs had been deemed ineligible to continue in the playoffs. The ruling stemmed from Rule 26A of the New York State Public High School Athletic Association handbook, which addresses eligibility and athlete representation.
In a message posted to the school website Friday, Schultz said the district disagreed with Section IV’s decision and was pursuing additional remedies.
“Again, we strongly disagree that this rule should apply in this situation, and the failure to apply for a waiver should not hinder the entire team or sports season,” Schultz wrote.
The district had requested assistance through state Sen. Peter Oberacker’s office and was preparing another appeal through NYSPHSAA. Schultz acknowledged the limited time available to seek a reversal but said the district would continue advocating for the student-athletes.
“This ruling does not change what our athletes accomplished or how proud we are of them,” Schultz wrote.
In a follow-up message posted to the school’s Facebook page Saturday, Nov. 14, Schultz thanked community members, parents, athletes and neighboring school districts for their support during the appeals process.
“The many letters we received from various stakeholders have not gone unnoticed, and they were shared with decision makers outside of Delaware County throughout the process,” Schultz wrote.
Schultz said the district took extensive steps to challenge the decision, contacting state government officials, its legal team, Section IV and NYSPHSAA, and ultimately sending a letter directly to the state education commissioner. Despite those efforts, the original forfeit decision remained in place.
Schultz said the district understood the rule being applied and the reasoning behind it but disagreed that the circumstances involving the Bulldogs were what the rule was intended to address.
“I do not agree that the situation our athletes are being punished for is what this rule was meant to address,” Schultz wrote. “If NYSPHSAA feels that it is, then so be it, but the district should be penalized in some other appropriate way.”
Schultz also questioned whether the decision reflected the stated goals of NYSPHSAA, including maintaining minimum eligibility standards and providing a means to resolve disputed athletic contests.
“In my opinion, neither of those was achieved in this situation, and they will continue to go unmet if the organization keeps punishing student athletes in situations like this one,” Schultz wrote.
While acknowledging the disappointment surrounding the decision, Schultz said the district would continue advocating for changes to prevent other teams from experiencing similar circumstances.
“To our players and coaches, your hard work, dedication, and the season you put together will not be forgotten, and we could not be prouder of how you represented Delaware Academy,” Schultz wrote.
Schultz closed by thanking the community for standing behind the team, saying its support demonstrated the strength of the Delaware Academy community during a difficult time.