Letter to the Editor: An Accounting is Due to Us

Posted

Congratulations to The Reporter for regaining its century-long status as an official newspaper of Delaware County.  No other weekly paper comes close to fulfilling that role. Rescinding it seems an act of spite. And the Shepards have earned our gratitude for defending the First Amendment right to speak free of retribution from government.

We have read the Decker Advertising’s side of the story. When will Delaware County enlighten us with theirs? Only then can citizens fairly judge cause and effect. In the meantime, townspeople should question their supervisors, many recently reelected. Is it coincidence that this settlement was announced after election day?

For their troubles of more than four years, Decker Advertising was awarded only $28 thousand. The bulk of the settlement went to court costs of $129 thousand and attorney’s fees of $423 thousand. (While Decker Advertising/The Reporter was represented pro bono by the Cornell legal clinic, it was assisted by two firms from Albany and New York.)  However, those are only the costs to Delaware County from this settlement of $600 thousand.   We await an accounting of the costs of a defense by our county. Confided by a supervisor months ago, that bill had reached $1.5 million. Likewise, unaccounted for is how much of these expenses would be covered by us taxpayers and how much by insurance – which taxpayers can expect to be compensating insurers for with years of higher premiums.

Also congratulations to our board of supervisor for finally coming to their senses. Had this case gone to trial, expenses would have continued to mount, and most likely the county would have lost. There is clear and robust precedent from the Supreme Court of the United States for protecting freedom of the press. You wonder who was advising them.

Their mismanagement had turned a restoration of status in 2023 into a restoration of status in 2026 and a bill of over $2 million. You would think that supervisors would have learned from their past mistakes. Seven years ago, likely a similar price tag came with their pyrrhic victory: firing the Director of Social Services only a few weeks short of the end of her contract. Besides paying for months of administrative hearings after Scuderi-Hunter’s suspension, there were years of state and federal court cases and appeals after her firing.

Is this any way to run a county?

Brian Brock

Susan Barnett

Marjorie B. Kellogg

Franklin